Eight Mystery Necklace designs in gold and silver, $42 value

Mystery Necklace in its yellow Mystery Jewelry pouch, $42 value

Mystery Jewelry pouch

Mystery Necklace possible design: #102 in gold

Mystery Necklace possible design: #103 in gold

Mystery Necklace possible design: #105 in gold

Mystery Necklace possible design: #107 in gold

Mystery Necklace possible design: #116 in gold

Mystery Necklace possible design: #117 in gold

Mystery Necklace possible design: #121 in gold

Mystery Necklace possible design: #108 in silver
Regular price$42
SAVE $0
/

Black Friday Sale

Cyber Monday Sale

Buy More, Save More

Limited stock. Discount auto-applies at checkout.

  1. Spend $100+Get 20% off
  2. Spend $200+Get 30% off
  3. Spend $300+Get 40% off
  4. Spend $350+Receive a
    Mystery Necklace
  • Same Day, Next Day Shipping
  • Golden Lifetime Guarantee
  • Description

    A mystery necklace worth $42, uniquely designed in Hawai’i. Choose gold or silver and we’ll pick the design.

    It’s just like opening a blind box: you won’t know which necklace is inside until the pouch is open. That makes it a sweet surprise to gift, too.

    Materials:
    316L Stainless Steel: Known for its hypoallergenic properties and resistance to tarnish, this durable base metal ensures lasting wear and comfort.
    14k Gold: Our premium 14k gold plating provides a luxurious finish that stands the test of time, offering the perfect blend of quality and affordability.

    Details:
    Style and length vary by necklace.

  • Shipping

    Processing Time

    • Orders ship same or next day from California.
    • Same-Day Cutoff: Order by 12 PM PST on business days for same-day shipping; later orders process the next business day.

    Delivery Speed

    • USA Economy: 3-5 business days
    • USA Priority: 1-3 business days
    • USA Overnight: Next business day
    • Canada & Australia: 4-8 business days

    Shipping Cost

    USA:

    • Economy: Free over $100 USD, $3.95 under $100
    • Priority: $14.88
    • Overnight: $32.88

    Canada & Australia:

    • Free over $100 USD, $18.99 under $100

    Customs: Duties/taxes not included in shipping cost

  • Returns

    30-day returns from delivery date


    Items must be unworn, unused, in original packaging (rings must include tags)


    Final sale / clearance items and free mystery gifts are not returnable


    How to return: Email hello@staygoldenhi.com with your order number → we’ll send return instructions. You cover return shipping.


    Refund timing: Processed within 3–5 business days once we receive and inspect the item (shipping fees not refunded)


    Damaged or wrong item? Contact us right away and we’ll fix it

    Lost or stolen mail: Please contact USPS directly (we can provide details to support your claim)

  • Golden Lifetime Guarantee

    We stand behind our jewelry — and we mean it.

    If your piece ever fades, tarnishes, or loses its shine, we'll replace it. No questions asked. No hoops to jump through.

    How it works:

    • Email us a photo of the affected item at hello@staygoldenhi.com.
    • Include your order number or proof of purchase.
    • We'll be in touch with you regarding the next step.

    Our pieces are made to live in — swim, sweat, sleep, repeat. If they don't hold up, we'll make it right.

  • FAQs

    Does our jewelry tarnish?
    Our 14k gold plated pieces are tarnish-free and will maintain their vibrant look as long as they are properly taken care of. Our jewelry can be worn in the water and in the ocean.

    Does our jewelry turn green?
    The short answer is no :) All of our products (unless stated otherwise) are made out of stainless steel. We stay away from cheap metals that turn your skin green, such as brass, zinc, nickel, alloy and copper.

    Are these made out of real/solid gold?
    Any item that specifies that it is gold-plated in the description box is plated in 14k gold. Solid gold products would be far more expensive than the prices we are able to offer. We strive to balance affordability and quality!

    Is plated jewelry bad?
    Plated jewelry is only bad when you try to plate cheap metals, such as brass, zinc, nickel, alloy and copper.

    How do I clean my jewelry?
    Wash with warm soapy water and a soft cloth! It's that simple :)

    We only use the best materials for Stay Golden babes ♡

Order within [TIMER] and it ships out of our warehouse by [DATE]
Description

A mystery necklace worth $42, uniquely designed in Hawai’i. Choose gold or silver and we’ll pick the design.

It’s just like opening a blind box: you won’t know which necklace is inside until the pouch is open. That makes it a sweet surprise to gift, too.

Materials:
316L Stainless Steel: Known for its hypoallergenic properties and resistance to tarnish, this durable base metal ensures lasting wear and comfort.
14k Gold: Our premium 14k gold plating provides a luxurious finish that stands the test of time, offering the perfect blend of quality and affordability.

Details:
Style and length vary by necklace.

Golden Lifetime Guarantee

We stand behind our jewelry — and we mean it.

If your piece ever fades, tarnishes, or loses its shine, we'll replace it. No questions asked. No hoops to jump through.

How it works:

  • Email us a photo of the affected item at hello@staygoldenhi.com.
  • Include your order number or proof of purchase.
  • We'll be in touch with you regarding the next step.

Our pieces are made to live in — swim, sweat, sleep, repeat. If they don't hold up, we'll make it right.

Shipping

Processing Time

  • Orders ship same or next day from California.
  • Same-Day Cutoff: Order by 12 PM PST on business days for same-day shipping; later orders process the next business day.

Delivery Speed

  • USA Economy: 3-5 business days
  • USA Priority: 1-3 business days
  • USA Overnight: Next business day
  • Canada & Australia: 4-8 business days

Shipping Cost

USA:

  • Economy: Free over $100 USD, $3.95 under $100
  • Priority: $14.88
  • Overnight: $32.88

Canada & Australia:

  • Free over $100 USD, $18.99 under $100

Customs: Duties/taxes not included in shipping cost

Returns

REFUND / RETURNS POLICY:



At Stay Golden HI, we're all about creating pieces that celebrate our roots and help you feel proud of what you wear. With that, we understand that sometimes things don’t work out and that’s okay!

If you’re not totally satisfied with your jewelry, you may return the product for a refund under the following conditions:

1. Items must be returned within 30 days from the delivery date.

2. Jewelry must be unworn or unused, with tags (for rings), and in its original packaging.

3. Items marked as final sale or clearance are non-refundable.

4. Free mystery gifts are not eligible for return or exchange.

If you decide to return the jewelry for a refund or exchange:

1. Send us an email at hello@staygoldenhi.com with your order number and the items that you’d like to return.

2. Our team will provide the return instructions, including our return address.

3. You can purchase the shipping label from your preferred postal service to return the item.

Once we receive and assess your return, we’ll process your refund for the purchase amount of the item, excluding shipping fees. Refunds will take 3-5 business days to be posted back on your account.

Damages and Issues

We want you to love every piece you receive. If your order arrives damaged, defective, or includes the wrong item, please reach out to us as soon as possible so we can make it right.

We carefully prepare each order to ensure safe delivery. Once it’s on its way, delays or delivery issues can occasionally happen. If your package goes missing or stolen, we recommend reaching out to USPS for help with locating or filing a claim. Need details from us to support that? Just let us know and we’ll be happy to help!

FAQs

Does our jewelry tarnish?
Our 14k gold plated pieces are tarnish-free and will maintain their vibrant look as long as they are properly taken care of. Our jewelry can be worn in the water and in the ocean.

Does our jewelry turn green?
The short answer is no :) All of our products (unless stated otherwise) are made out of stainless steel. We stay away from cheap metals that turn your skin green, such as brass, zinc, nickel, alloy and copper.

Are these made out of real/solid gold?
Any item that specifies that it is gold-plated in the description box is plated in 14k gold. Solid gold products would be far more expensive than the prices we are able to offer. We strive to balance affordability and quality!

Is plated jewelry bad?
Plated jewelry is only bad when you try to plate cheap metals, such as brass, zinc, nickel, alloy and copper.

How do I clean my jewelry?
Wash with warm soapy water and a soft cloth! It's that simple :)

We only use the best materials for Stay Golden babes ♡

  • Watersafe
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Trendy designs
  • Golden Lifetime Guarantee
  • Ready to gift

The ultimate gift

Our packaging

Every order arrives in our signature yellow box: jewelry framed in the plumeria window, ready to gift as-is.

More about gifting

Customer Reviews

Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 467 reviews.

Customer photo review of Mystery Necklace

I was very pleased with my mystery necklace! It was the first piece i decided to rock when I got my order in. Beautifully made and perfect length.

Mystery Necklace

Store owner replied: Yay! Thank you and enjoy wearing it! 💛

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I absolutely loveeeeeee their jewelry so much!! it’s my everyday !!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Yay! Thank you for the feedback and enjoy wearing it!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

the chain in the middle with the heart pendant is the mystery one and i have to be honest…hands down my top two faves at the moment. if i could purchase the mystery jewelry alone i would so do it. the design is adorable and is so lightweight and doesn’t get caught on my clothes

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

this cross was the mystery necklace/jewelry and i actually really like it! this is amazing!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

It’s so cute and I love how it matched with an item in my order~! Mahalo nui loa for such cute jewelry~!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The mystery jewlery that I got is so cute!! I have been looking for a gold and pink necklace for a while, and this one is perfect

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Sounds like it's meant to be! Thank you for the feedback and enjoy wearing it!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Got this cute necklace as a mystery item, & my daughter loves it!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The necklace is really nice, I was so hoping for the engraved letter locket. The lock itself is weighty and chain is sturdy.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

My boyfriend loved the locket necklace!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Aww. Glad he likes it! Thank you for sharing the Stay Golden love to your boyfriend!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

First order with Stay Golden! I hoped the mystery would be something totally out of my comfort zone, or just something I normally wouldn’t choose…. I got the moon (short disc chain) necklace & I absolutely adore it! Fits right in with my other jewelry. <3

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Amazing necklace stack! We're glad that you're loving the pieces that you got. Thank you for the feedback and enjoy wearing them!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

My mystery gift was a heart necklace with a W on it. Although I think the necklace is cute, for personal reasons I don't feel attachment to my last name so I won't be using the pendant. I did take the chain for another pendant I had, and have no complaints about that. I think it's a good mystery item and I understand S was likely out, so I don't hold it against them! Thank you for the gift.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: We hear you! Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding the Mystery Jewelry. We'll do our best to improve next time!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

it's sweet to be given a free mystery jewelry! almost like gachapon haha. really loved what i got, and still in lovely condition <333

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: We're happy that you're loving the Mystery Jewelry! Thank you for the feedback and enjoy wearing it!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The free jewelry is always one of my favorite parts of ordering from SG 🩷 the bow necklace is so so cute!!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: We love seeing you wear our collection! Thank you for always supporting us and for the feedback!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The mystery jewelry was more than I expected! It’s a beautiful little gold lock with my last initial and I love showing it off 🥰🔒

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I honestly love it and I’m able to stack

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Love this necklace stack! Thank you for the feedback and enjoy wearing them!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Never have I ever received a free gift that was so specific to myself. When I tell you I *GASPED* after opening this and seeing it. It literally felt like a gift from a long distance friend. I'm going on about 10pc from this company and I gift their pieces when I can. If you haven't made a purchase yet what are you waiting for??

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I can not express how grateful I am that we receive a free mystery jewellery piece, THEY ALWAYS EATTTTTT

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I purchased two necklaces and received a free mystery gift. I actually screamed when I opened it because I wasn’t expecting much but it’s a legitimately cute chain, not just a throw away item!! AND they sent a chain with my initial on it which has to be the most thoughtful free gift I’ve ever received 🥹😭 I’m obsessed with this gift, thank you so much!!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

i’ve been wearing all my pieces everyday and they’re holding up fantastic!! so happy to finally find affordable and long lasting gold jewelry ✨🤭

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Yay! We're glad that you're loving the quality and fit of the pieces you got. Enjoy wearing them!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

It’s like you guys read my mind?? My friend and I were talking about lock necklaces and how she sees me with one in the future…and what did I get? A locket necklace?! I adore it, and can’t wait to purchase from here again!!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I really like that the charms for the earrings are interchangeable and they have not tarnished.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: We're glad that you're enjoying botht he Huggies and charm pairing! Thank you for the feedback!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

the mystery necklace was so cute!!! so happy it was gold like the rest of my pieces, i adore the attention to detail <3

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I absolutely adore the necklaces and the bracelet! Thank you for matching my free mystery necklace to the bracelet i ordered!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Cutesy stack! We're happy that you're loving the pieces you got. Thank you for the feedback!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

couldn't have asked for a better piece!! 🙈💕

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The free gift is the16 inch gold chain above my silver necklaces. So sexy to layer. I have sensitive skin. Love that I can’t even tell it’s on.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Love love LOVE my necklaces! My mystery gift was a lock necklace with my initial and I absolutely fell in love with it. Beautiful, great quality, most definitely buying more!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Amazing stack! We're happy to hear that you're loving the look and quality of the necklaces you got. We can't wait to see which piece you'll be adding to your stack!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The locket with my initial on it is a great addition to my existing necklaces

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: We're happy seeing you build your Stay Golden necklace stack! Thank you for the support and for the feedback!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The mystery gift was spot on! I’m metal mixing so the silver pendant fits perfectly. Love the lock! Worn it everyday since I got it

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Yay! We're happy to become part of your metal mixing journey! Thank you for the feedback!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

thought was put into jewelry! silver just like everything else i purchased and the letter is my last name!

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer video review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I absolutely love this necklace!! It is so cute and comfortable to wear. Haven’t taken it off since I got it

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Ahhhh I love the surprise gift! I gifted it to my honey and he loves wearing my initial 🤎 “it fits really comfortable, lightweight and doesn’t tangle with my other chains” -my man

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Yay! We're happy that you're both loving the pieces you got from us. Thank you for the feedback!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Decided to treat myself after a break up and get a new signature necklace, little did I know the free mystery one would be apart of that stack! I’m in love! Thank you for making me feel better and cuter! <3

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I love my surprise-free gift. It ended up being a lock necklace with my initials on it. It is such nice quality and I love that it was personalized to me! It also doesn't irritate my skin because I have very sensitive skin.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Yay! We're happy that you're loving the comfort of the pieces you got, including the Mystery Jewelry. Thank you for sharing your experience in wearing them!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Both necklaces are from StayGolden. I just love how well these 2 look together and even received a couple comments. I made my first purchase the beginning of the year after seeing an IG ad and have made 2 or 3 more since. You will not be disappointed.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Cutesy stack! Thank you for your continued support and love for our pieces. Cheers to your growing Stay Golden collection!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Received a gold locket necklace. Paired with dainty rope chain for a mixed metal effect. Very cute and has a nice weight to keep the necklace laying right. It has a longer chain but had a 2 inch adjustable length

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

Such a cute surprise! Has my initial engraved and I haven't taken it off since.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

The mystery jewelry is so fun and exciting! I’ve been using it to start my metal mixing jewelry because it makes me feel less scared to try silver hahaha.

FREE Mystery Jewelry

Store owner replied: Thank you for sharing your feedback about the Mystery Jewelry. We're excited to see your metal mixing journey. Please let us know how it goes!

Customer photo review of FREE Mystery Jewelry

I absolutely love the mystery jewelry! I never know what I’ll get each and every time and so far the pieces have been just as high quality as the rest of your pieces!

FREE Mystery Jewelry